What Is A Manuscript Evaluation?

A manuscript evaluation (or manuscript review) is a comprehensive assessment that gives you a clear roadmap with actionable feedback for revision. For written works that are in the completion stage, or near it, an editor’s perspective can be a critical instrument that helps the author identify areas for improvement so they become empowered to unlock their highest potential.

What You Get

A detailed 3-10 page report that includes:

• Overall story structure analysis – plot development, narrative flow, character motivations, consistency, pacing, and commercial viability

• Writing craft assessment – voice, tone, and dialogue effectiveness

• Margin comments - integrated notes within your manuscript, highlighting areas of strength and opportunities for improvement or clarity

• Concrete next steps – prioritized recommendations for revisions and strengthening

Best For

Authors who want professional feedback before investing in a full developmental edit, or those seeking validation that their manuscript is ready for the next level